Torbay Group logo
Minutes of the Torbay Catchment Group
Executive Meeting

WEDNESDAY 26th AUGUST 2009 at 7.30 pm

  1. Welcome, attendance and apologies

    The Chair, Phillip Mellon welcomed those present to the meeting at 7.32pm.

    ATTENDANCES: Phil Mellon, Andrew Marshall, Keith Smith, Graeme Heighton, Lesley Hart, Maurice McCormick, Phillip Marshall, Adrian Stratico (Water Corp), Phil Attwell (guest / local resident) & Robert Fenn (guest / City of Albany)

    APOLOGIES: Terri Harwood, Dave Broadhurst, John Blaney-Murphy

  2. Guest local resident Phil Attwell

    Phil attended the meeting at the invitation of the Chair, Phil Mellon to address and respond to various comments and references to his Cuthbert business appearing in our minutes that he found to be inaccurate and of concern to him. Phil made reference to a question that had been minuted back in 2007 regarding his businesses' water useage. Phil tabled a copy of the Coffey Environmental Consultants report which shows that in any calendar year the water he uses is less than the water returned & that the returned water is in fact cleaner. Phil encouraged the group to read the full report. Phil then referred to the July 2009 minutes which suggested he has a sand blasting business. Phil clarified for the meeting that he has no such business. He does own a sand blaster, but it is rarely used. Also the question regarding the 'illegal' clearing of some vegetation on the Water Corp drain, was again nothing to do with himself. It was clearing organised through Wayne Marwick of the Water Corp and was carried out by Denmark Excavations.

    The April 2009 minutes had noted a 'road project commenced from this site' which again is nothing to do with him and Phil contested the comment in item 6.4 under Attwell's Brickworks that his business had 'grown'. He is currently only operating about 2 days per week.

    He expressed great concern that such negative comments reflect on him personally and on his business and he would rather we approached him directly if we had any issues or concerns. Phil also encouraged the group to look up the West Australian State Administrative Tribunal website to read up on his business case.

    The Committee expressed regret and apologised for having minuted any incorrect statements, whilst also explaining that the community brings issues of concern to the Committee for follow up and investigation. The Committee thanked Phil for attending and providing this feedback, acknowledging both that they would approach him directly in the future and the need to be more cautious when following up on the community's concerns.

    Phil thanked the Committee for giving him the opportunity to meet with them directly & left the meeting at approx. 8.00 pm.

  3. Catchment Signage

    Robert Fenn, Executive Director, Development Services from the City of Albany was welcomed to the meeting. Lesley explained where the TCG had got to with the design and siting of 4 proposed signs in the catchment. Robert said that Main Roads allow for 'information signage' to go in their road reserve areas. Main concerns are the amount of wording, size of lettering, plus the materials used eg friable poles which will readily collapse if there is a collision. Robert explained that if the signs were to be erected within private property boundaries that would involve a sign licence application, whilst any application for putting a sign on road reserve required a permit. If planing to use a Main Roads reserve area, underground cables would have to be considered/checked.

    Robert said he would follow up with the names of the relevant persons to speak with in the City of Albany the following day. The Committee thanked Robert for his time and input and he left the meeting at approx. 8.20 pm.

  4. Confirmation of previous minutes and matters arising :

    Confirmation of minutes of Executive Meeting 15 July 2009
    Moved: Graeme Heighton
    Seconded: Phillip Marshall

    Item 7.3 Undiup Creek:
    Action: Lesley to check whether this testing (water quality/pesticide?)has been conducted - Not followed up as yet

  5. Correspondence and matters arising:

    5.1 Inwards:

    5.2 Outwards:

  6. Finance Report:

  7. Staff Report: Lesley Hart tabled her report.

  8. General Business:

  9. Other Business:

  10. Close:

    The meeting was declared closed at 9.50pm

    Next Meetings:
    Annual General Meeting: Wednesday 16 September 2009
    Executive meeting: Wednesday 7 October 2009

    home next